Bank of China

The Bank of China is the country’s second-oldest bank having been established back in 1912.

banner

It was originally founded as the Central Bank of China by the Republican government but the current iteration of the bank was established in 1949. As with most Chinese banks, it is completely state-owned and is headquartered in Beijing, although it has multiple subsidiaries located in more than 60 different countries around the world.

Bank Of China

As of September 2023, the Bank of China is the ninth-largest bank in the world by market capitalization and the fourth-largest by total assets held. The Financial Stability Board considers the Bank of China a systemically important bank and a critical institution in the world’s second-largest economy. When it received this designation in 2011, it was the first bank in an emerging market to ever be deemed a systemically important bank.

The Bank of China is a commercial bank that has well over 300 million active clients. It offers a long list of financial services including personal banking, investing, mortgage loans, and insurance. There is also a significant corporate side to the bank that serves some of China’s largest companies.

In terms of its major subsidiaries, Bank of China’s largest operations outside of China are in Hong Kong and Canada. While the Bank of China operates on every inhabited continent, this business accounts for less than 10% of the company’s overall revenue.

A History of the Bank of China

Bank Of China

The Bank of China was officially founded in 1912 but can trace its roots back as early as 1905 as the Daqing Hubu Bank. This bank was first established by the Qing government but was transformed in 1912 by the Sun Yat Sen government into the Central Bank of China. The founder was Chen Jintao who was the head of financial reform under President Sun Yat Sen’s regime.

Things remained this way until 1949 when the Chinese Civil War came to an end. At this point, the government split the bank into multiple different operations. One of these divisions went to Taiwan with the Kuomintang government and would eventually become the privatized bank known as the International Commercial Bank of China. By 1978, the Bank of China was focused more on international finance and to this day, remains China’s most globalized bank.

In 2002, the Bank of China merged with the Jiaotong Bank to form a new entity called the Mega International Commercial Bank. Today, the Bank of China is the Mainland China operation of this merger. The Bank of China is the second-oldest bank in China after only the Bank of Communications which was founded in 1908 and based out of Shanghai.

The Bank of China is a majority state-owned entity but it is also publicly traded on the stock exchanges in both Shanghai and Hong Kong. Its stock is a component of both the Hang Seng Index and the SSE 50. At the time, the Bank of China was the first bank to ever have both an H-Share and A-Share offering and be dual-listed in both Hong Kong and Shanghai. Although it was founded in 1912, the Bank of China did not hold its IPO until June 2006.

Bank of China’s Stock

The Bank of China offers both H-Shares and A-Shares and trades on both the Shanghai Stock Exchange and the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. The respective ticker symbols for the Bank of China are SSE: 601988 and SEHK: 3988. In China, the H-Shares of a company trade on the Hong Kong exchange and are typically more liquid and available to more international traders. The A-Shares trade in Shanghai, and are only available to Chinese citizens.
Bank Of China

As a result, most Chinese stocks will differ in price depending on which exchange you check. Not only do the different exchanges offer a wide range of trading volume, but there is also a difference when listed in Hong Kong Dollars (HKD) and Chinese Yuan. As of September 2023, the Bank of China has a market capitalization of about $139 billion and is just ahead of American bank Morgan Stanley in value.

Neither of the Bank of China’s stocks are trading for very high prices right now. The company’s H-Shares are trading for about 2.76 CNY per share and the A-Shares at about $3.79 HKD per share. Historically, neither stock has provided much in the way of shareholder returns either. If you invested in the A-Shares at the 2006 IPO, you would have seen a return of just 2.99%. But if you invested in the H-Shares in 2006, you would be down by more than 17%.
banner

In Hong Kong, the Bank of China’s stock has a massive share float of more than 83 billion shares. On the Shanghai exchange, the Bank of China has a share float of more than 210 billion shares. With such share dilution, it is not surprising that the stock has not returned any meaningful gains over the past 18 years.

One more indication that the Bank of China might not be a strong stock to invest in is its low institutional ownership. The H-Shares of the stock only have a 22.10% institutional ownership, while the A-Shares are even lower at only 1.11%. The reason for this is likely due to the fact that the A-Shares in Shanghai are highly illiquid and more than 90% of the shares are owned by insiders and the Chinese government.

Perhaps another red flag for the stock is that the state-owned Central Huijin Investment Co. owns a majority of the shares. Its position is equal to about 64% of the company, which means that one institutional entity, in this case, the Chinese government, has a large say in the future of the bank. This is one of many reasons why many investors choose to steer clear of investing in Chinese companies.

Bank of China’s Dividend

Like most major banks, the Bank of China pays out a respectable dividend yield. So while these stocks might not be providing much in the way of capital appreciation, the dividend has held up nicely over the years and has surely returned some of the equity to shareholders. As of September 2023, the H-Shares dividend yield sits at just north of 9.0% while the A-Shares yield is just over 6.10%. Both dividends are paid out to shareholders on a semi-annual basis in July and September.

The high dividend yield is more of a result of the stock price struggling and it likely isn’t a red flag as it would be with other stocks. The dividend payout ratio for the Bank of China sits around 30% so the dividend distribution is relatively safe. This ratio calculates the total number of dividends paid to shareholders as a percentage of the company’s net income. So only 30% of the Bank of China’s net income is paid out as dividends each year. In Hong Kong, the 5-year average dividend yield sits at 7.73% while in Shanghai this figure is 5.81%.

The Bank of China’s dividend growth rate has not been consistent over the years. The 10-year dividend growth rate has only grown by an average of 2.21%. Over the past five years, this growth rate has been better with an average increase of about 5.63% per year. The Bank of China does not raise its dividend each year and in fact, is not shy about lowering the dividend yield in some years.

Bank of China Products and Services

The Bank of China is first and foremost a commercial bank that serves the citizens and corporations of China and other countries around the world. A vast majority of the bank’s revenue is from business from within Mainland China. As of June 2023, the Bank of China’s commercial banking accounted for 93.5% of the company’s net income.
Yuan

Consumer-facing services from the Bank of China include personal savings and wealth management, investment banking, personal loans, insurance, and credit cards. As with nearly every bank and financial platform in China, the Bank of China is fully integrated with mobile banking as well as Chinese super apps like WeChat and AliPay. The Bank of China even offers a Taobao credit card, which is Alibaba’s top eCommerce site in the country.

The Bank of China is one of the country’s largest lenders and offers a wide selection of personal loans for consumers. These include mortgage loans, student loans, auto loans, and investment loans. Corporate loans actually make up about 66% of the Bank of China’s lending business as of June 2023, with Mainland China corporate loans accounting for more than 50% of the total lending business.

On top of that, the Bank of China provides a long list of enterprise services for China-based businesses. This includes a wide variety of enterprise insurance options for engineering, cargo transportation, machinery breakdown, and employer’s liability. It also has an enterprise annuity service for companies who want to offer their employees a pension plan. Finally, the Bank of China shows its global influence by providing Chinese companies with local account management services for overseas subsidiaries.

What Does the Future Hold for the Bank of China?

As a financial institution, the Bank of China likely isn’t going anywhere. It has a long history of prosperity in China and as the bank with the largest international footprint, it has a safer foundation than some other Chinese banks. The bank’s role as one of the largest lenders in China is also critical to the domestic economy.

But as an investment, what does the long-term hold for the Bank of China? In all honesty, the Bank of China’s stock has never been a great investment for shareholders. Neither the A-Shares nor H-Shares have provided much in the way of an exciting return. While the dividends are solid and likely safe, the overall capital returns of the Bank of China have severely lagged investments in American banks or even broader indexes.
banner

As with other Chinese banks like the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), the large share count is playing a role in keeping the stock price depressed. There is also the concern about these banks being state-owned and operated. While that might not immediately appear in the price of the stock, it does put a limit on how well these companies can perform.

To be fair, Chinese bank stocks have been under immense pressure in 2023 as the global economy struggles and a return to economic growth remains stunted. On top of that, China has been hit with issues in its real estate development sector and increasing intervention from the Chinese Communist Party.

One interesting result of the weakness in the Chinese market is that companies with depressed stock prices have been undertaking steady stock buybacks. Stock buybacks are usually a positive result for shareholders as it shows that the company believes its own stock is undervalued, and it also boosts shareholder equity.

Is this enough to make the Bank of China a good investment? If you are bullish on China for the long run, then you can make a case to buy cheap Chinese bank stocks right now. While this seems like a good value investment, remember that the Bank of China has had a long history of underperforming with negative shareholder returns.

As a business, the Bank of China should continue to benefit from a rapidly growing middle class and one day, the Chinese economy should return to a period of growth. But as an investment, it’s hard to forecast if the stock will ever buck its historical trend and provide shareholders with a market-beating return. Given the stock’s abysmal performance over the past 18 years, there are other investments with better potential long-term risk-reward profiles.

No Financial or Investment Advice: The content on this Site is for informational purposes only, you should not construe any such information or other material as legal, tax, investment, financial, or other advice. Nothing contained on our Site constitutes a solicitation, recommendation, endorsement, or offer by Smartvest Securities to buy or sell securities or other financial instruments in this or in in any other jurisdiction in which such solicitation or offer would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction. Nothing in the Site constitutes professional and/or financial advice, nor does any information on the Site constitute a comprehensive or complete statement of the matters discussed or the law relating thereto. Smartvest Securities is not a fiduciary by virtue of any person’s or entity’s use of or access to the Site. You alone assume the sole responsibility of evaluating the merits and risks associated with the use of any information or other content on the Site before making any decisions based on such information or other content. In exchange for using the Site, you agree not to hold Smartvest Securities, or its affiliates liable for any possible claim for damages arising from any decision you make based on information or other content made available to you through the Site.